Oriel faces growing pressure over Nathan Cofnas event as JCR motion calls for withdrawal of facilities

An Oriel JCR motion seeks to condemn the invitation to controversial speaker Nathan Cofnas, citing concerns about student safety

Oriel College is facing growing pressure over its decision to host controversial speaker Nathan Cofnas, after a motion submitted to the College's JCR called on the College to withdraw its facilities from the event.

The motion, proposed by members of Oriel JCR, proposes a statement to condemn the invitation to Cofnas in the "strongest possible terms", arguing that his views on race, intelligence and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) undermine the College's commitment to an inclusive community.

It also raises concerns about the safety and wellbeing of students amid potential protests outside the College, stating that some students whose rooms overlook Oriel Street and Oriel Square fear being directly targeted by demonstrators. The motion urges Oriel to withdraw its facilities from the event, which is scheduled to take place in the Harris Lecture Theatre on 17 November.

Cofnas has been invited to speak at Oriel by the Oxon Universities' Reform Society (OURS), a student society affiliated with Reform UK. The event, titled An Evening with Nathan Cofnas: Is DEI Undermining Higher Education?, has also prompted an open letter calling for its cancellation.

Students raise concerns over safety and discrimination

The proposed statement from the JCR raises the point that Cofnas's publications and public statements are incompatible with the College's stated commitment to building supportive and inclusive communities.

It cites Cofnas's assertion that there is "obviously a connection between intelligence and human worth", alongside his suggestion that Black people would disappear "from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment" under a meritocratic system.

The statement describes these arguments, particularly Cofnas's reliance on IQ as a measure of intelligence and its relationship to human worth, as "denigrating and dehumanising" to Black members of the College community. It emphasises that every Oriel student has earned their place through Oxford's competitive admissions process and should not be subjected to rhetoric that undermines their academic achievements.

The statement also highlights concerns about the prospect of demonstrations outside the College in the wake of calls for protest from Black Lives Matter UK, Every Day Racism, Oxford Students' Coalition Against Racism and Stand Up To Racism. They have expressed that the resulting hostility towards the College has left some students fearful of being targeted.

It further questions whether allowing the event to proceed is consistent with Oriel's commitment to maintaining a working and learning environment free from discrimination and harassment.

The statement concludes by calling on the College to withdraw its facilities from the event, citing risks to the physical safety and wellbeing of College members.

Oriel’s security considerations remain unclear

The student concerns come amid questions about Oriel’s approach to the risks associated with hosting Cofnas.

In a published statement regarding the event, the College said it takes seriously "the security implications of events and the safety of its members" when considering booking requests. 

The statement emphasised Oriel's commitment to freedom of expression within the law, including the expression of views that others may find offensive. It also highlighted that the event had been booked by committee members of a registered student society and that permitting it to take place should not be understood as an endorsement of Cofnas's views.

However, the College's lack of detail concerning its security considerations leaves questions about how it has balanced its commitments in this particular case. Although the event was organised by a student society rather than Oriel itself, it will take place within the College, where students live and study.

The JCR motion brings these questions into focus, placing student welfare and the potential consequences of hosting the event at the centre of the debate.

Who is Nathan Cofnas?

Cofnas is an American philosopher specialising in the philosophy of biology and ethics. He holds a DPhil in Philosophy from Oxford and has previously held academic positions at Cambridge and Ghent University.

His academic and public writing has focused on hereditarianism, the view that genetic factors contribute to human traits and behavioural differences, including intelligence. More controversially, Cofnas has argued that genetic differences contribute to average differences in intelligence between racial populations, and describes himself as a ‘race realist’.

His critics dispute both the scientific basis and the wider implications of his arguments. The concern is not simply that his conclusions are problematic, but that his claims about racial differences are presented as scientific findings without sufficient evidence.

A career shaped by controversy

Cofnas’ unsupported claims attracted significant criticism during his time as a Fellow at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, with the College subsequently ending his research affiliation. Cofnas later moved to Ghent University, where his appointment also attracted opposition and scrutiny.

More recently, however, he has gained attention for publicising allegations of plagiarism against the late Professor Jason Arday, the Cambridge sociologist who became the University's youngest Black professor in 2023. Liverpool John Moores University, where Arday completed his doctorate, had previously investigated plagiarism concerns levelled against him and concluded that his degree should stand. Arday disputed the allegations of academic misconduct. The controversy became particularly sensitive following Arday's death in August 2026, and has intensified criticism of Cofnas, particularly among those who view his interventions as part of a wider pattern of targeting Black academics.

Why has the Reform Society invited him?

The invitation was issued by OURS, a student society linked with political party Reform UK. The society's programme includes speakers from the political far-right, among them Reform MP Andrew Rosindell and Traditional Unionist Voice leader Jim Allister.

Cofnas's invitation appears consistent with a programme focused on challenging what the society regards as prevailing political and institutional orthodoxies.

In its public defence of the event, OURS characterised Cofnas as having faced institutional discrimination. It argued that providing him with a platform would help address what it sees as a lack of intellectual diversity within universities.

Although the event is advertised as a discussion of diversity, equity and inclusion in higher education, Cofnas's public profile extends into more contentious topics of race, genetics and intelligence. Moreover, the scheduled event takes the form of a speech rather than a debate, with attendance restricted to members of the Oxford Reform Society. Non-members are unable to attend, whilst members of other political societies are ineligible to join; the opportunity for Cofnas’ views to be challenged or critically engaged with is consequently heavily restricted.

What does Oriel owe its students?

Oriel's position is that it must uphold lawful freedom of expression while also maintaining an environment free from discrimination and harassment.

Its response confirms that security and member safety are considered when assessing booking requests. It does not, however, explain how those considerations were applied to Cofnas's event.

The issue at hand is not simply whether controversial speakers should be permitted to speak, but also what responsibility the College has towards the people who live and study alongside the event. The proposed JCR motion highlights the difficulty of separating these responsibilities from the role of the College as a host institution. The distinction Oriel has made between hosting and endorsing a speaker does not resolve questions surrounding student welfare.

With the event scheduled for 17 November, the JCR's consideration of the motion represents a further challenge to the College's decision. Whether Oriel will reconsider its position, and how it will address the concerns raised by its students, remains to be seen.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Second Coming: why the Far Right is becoming ‘more Christian’